The Supreme Court of Wyoming recently rejected claims by a party that had largely prevailed in arbitration, but asserted that it should have received its fees, and that the arbitrator incorrectly decided several issues.
Fork Road, LLC owned part of a building that it purchased from JAMD, LLC. Mountain Business Center, LLC (MBC) was a tenant in that building. JAMD requested, on behalf of Fork Road, that MBC provide information about subtenants. MBC provided certain information, but withheld other information. Fork Road and MBC ended up in arbitration over that withholding and various other issues related to MBC’s lease. The arbitrator ruled in favor of MBC on certain claims and Fork Road on other claims, but ultimately awarded MBC nearly $24,000. MBC argued that it was the prevailing party and sought its fees, but the arbitrator declined to award them because this was a “mixed outcome” case, in which both parties prevailed on certain claims.
MBC challenged the award, arguing that the arbitrator had exceeded his authority because one of Fork Road’s witnesses had “waived” certain claims by Fork Road, but the arbitrator had nevertheless decided those claims. MBC also argued that it was the prevailing party and therefore entitled to fees and that the arbitrator erred by not applying the “first to breach rule” and holding that Fork Road had been the first to materially breach the lease.
The Supreme Court of Wyoming rejected MBC’s claims noting, “MBC cite[d] no authority that testimony by a lay witness on the substantial acts at issue may be used by party to limit its opponent’s claims.” It also held that the arbitrator did not have to award MBC fees even if it was true, as MBC argued, that MBC had prevailed on the “central issue” in the case. The court also held that the arbitrator did not commit manifest error by not applying the “first to breach rule,” where MBC had stayed in the building after Fork Road allegedly breached the lease.
Mountain Business Center, LLC v. Fork Road, LLC, No. 2-22 WY 147 (Wyo. Nov. 23, 2022).