Diane Koken, the Pennsylvania Insurance Commissioner, is the Statutory Liquidator for Legion Insurance Company and Villanova Insurance Company. In this case, Koken, as Liquidator, sought to recover more than $4 million in premiums and commissions allegedly due to the insurance companies pursuant to a Limited Agency Agreement between Legion and American Patriot Insurance Agency (“Patriot”). Patriot denied liability, alleging Legion perpetrated a fraud upon Patriot in relation to a “Rent-a-Captive” workers’ compensation program. During depositions of two of Legion’s former executives, Defendants’ counsel attempted to inquire into this fraud issue, but counsel for the Liquidator objected on the basis of attorney-client privilege. Defendants filed a motion to overrule the Liquidator’s claim of privilege pursuant to the crime/fraud exception, which the court denied in May 2006. That decision was affirmed in December 2006.
The defendants recently asked the court to overrule the Liquidator’s claim of privilege as to conversations between Legion’s Executive Vice President, Glenn Partridge, and Legion’s General Counsel, Andrew Walsh. While the court agreed that conversations with Mr. Walsh were not per se privileged, the court stated it was not in a position to determine whether the privilege applied because Mr. Partridge has not been deposed. The court agreed to postpone Mr. Partridge’s deposition pending a ruling on the Liquidator’s motion for summary judgment. Koken v. American Patriot Ins. Agency, Inc., Case No. 05-C-1049 (N.D.Ill. March 23, 2007).