This matter came before the Northern District of New York on appeal from a Bankruptcy Court Order, awarding Richard Breeden, Chapter 11 trustee (the “Trustee”) of The Bennett Funding Group, judgment on the pleadings and dismissing the Ades and Berg Groups’ (the “Ades Investors”) counterclaims for imposition of a constructive trust upon the proceeds of a reinsurance policy allegedly covering the Ades Investors’ losses. The proceeds of the reinsurance policy were to be paid to the Trustee pursuant to the terms of a settlement agreement with Sphere Drake.
In a de novo review, the Court affirmed the Bankruptcy Court’s Order, concluding that the Ades Investors’ claim failed to satisfy all four elements applicable under New York law for the imposition of a constructive trust. Specifically, the Court concluded that while three of the four elements were satisfied, the fourth element, requiring a showing that the Trustee was unjustly enriched when he retained the settlement proceeds from Sphere Drake, was not met. In re: The Bennett Funding Group, Case No. 97-70049 (N.D.N.Y. July 10, 2007).