Amerisure successfully arbitrated a dispute with Global Re. Under the parties’ reinsurance agreement, arbitration was to be governed by Illinois law, though Amerisure is a Michigan-based company and Global Re is based in New York. Amerisure’s award was confirmed by an Illinois circuit court but the portion of it awarding attorney’s fees was vacated. Subsequently, Amerisure filed a one-count complaint in the circuit court seeking attorney’s fees pursuant to Illinois statute. The court dismissed Amerisure’s complaint, determining that New York law applied to the lawsuit and that New York law did not permit an award of attorney’s fees in this instance. While the parties agreed that Illinois law should apply to arbitration matters, there was no such provision governing litigation. Absent a governing choice of law provision, New York law applied because New York had the most significant contacts with the parties’ dispute. Amerisure Mutual Insurance Co. v. Global Reinsurance Corp. of America, Case No. 10 L 012665 (Ill. Cir. Ct. Nov. 7, 2012).
This post written by Ben Seessel.
See our disclaimer.