Week's Best Posts

Florida Governor signs new hurricane preparedness and insurance bill into law

January 26, 2007 by Carlton Fields

New Florida Governor Charlie Crist has signed his first bill into law, House Bill 1A from a special session of the Florida Legislature dealing with insurance rates for homeowners. One of the principal goals of the special session was to increase the availability and lower the cost of homeowners insurance, particularly in coastal areas. A House of Representatives staff analysis of the bill contains background information about the insurance market in Florida and the impact of the eight major hurricanes that hit Florida during the 2004 and 2005 hurricane seasons. The staff analysis reports that claims payments were made relating to the eight hurricanes totaling $33,346,477,364, and describes the resulting impact on the number of insurers writing homeowners coverage in the state, the cost of coverage and the cost of reinsurance.

This 176 page bill makes extensive changes to the Florida property insurance and reinsurance markets. The changes are summarized in the staff analysis. Among the changes is expanding the Florida Hurricane Catastrophe Fund to provide a “temporary emergency program” for the 2007, 2008 and 2009 hurricane seasons providing less expensive reinsurance for insurers. Savings from the reduced cost of reinsurance must be passed on to consumers. It is unclear what the impact of this new law will be on the reinsurance market, but a large amount of reinsurance premium may now be diverted from the private reinsurance market to the public avenues set up or modified in this bill.

New York adopts new regulations for insurance reserves

January 23, 2007 by Carlton Fields

The New York Department of Insurance has adopted revised regulations governing the valuation of individual and group accident and health insurance reserves and emergency regulations governing the valuation of life insurance reserves. The complete re-writing of the reserve requirements relating to accident and health insurance was the first revision of the regulations in that area since 1971. The changes include a change from the use of the 1964 Commissioners' Disability Tables to the 1986 tables, and the adoption, for the first time, of regulations for group insurance. The emergency regulations for life insurance were adopted due to the Department becoming aware that “some insurers have designed certain life insurance products with the clear intent of circumventing existing reserve standards.”

Court remands case to new arbitration panel for further proceedings

January 22, 2007 by Carlton Fields

After partially vacating an arbitration award as being in manifest disregard of law, a District Court has remanded the case to a new arbitration panel for further proceedings. The Court found it inappropriate to remand the case to the same arbitration panel for further proceedings relating to the issue as to which it had found that the panel had manifestly disregarded Pennsylvania law. Koken v. Cologne Reinsurance (Barbados) Ltd., Case No. 98-0678 (USDC MD Pa Dec. 5, 2006).

Court stays enforcement of arbitral award pending ruling by liquidation court on set off claim

January 18, 2007 by Carlton Fields

LDG Re reinsured workers' compensation and employers' liability risks retained by Legion Insurance and a related company under two quota share reinsurance agreements. LDG Re booked the reinsurance into a pool facility in which a number of companies participated, including Chartwell Reinsurance (which was later purchased by Trenwick America Reinsurance). When LDG failed to make timely payments under the quota share agreements, Legion demanded arbitration. A settlement was reached. When LDG allegedly failed to make payments required by the settlement agreement, Legion sought to reactivate the arbitration. LDG objected, contending that the dispute was not arbitrable and that the pool members were entitled to set off other debts owed to them by Legion. The panel entered an award purporting to enforce the settlement agreement, requiring a payment by LDG of over $5 million, not mentioning the set off request. Legion moved to confirm the award, and Trenwick moved to intervene in both the District Court action and in Legion's liquidation proceeding in Pennsylvania state court, seeking to assert a set off. In a Memorandum Opinion, followed by an Order and Judgment, the District Court confirmed the arbitration award, but stayed execution pending the submission by Legion or Trenwick of a motion in the liquidation proceeding seeking a ruling as to whether the claimed set off should be allowed. Koken v. LDG Re Corp., Case No. 06-81 (USDC ED Pa. Dec. 29, 2006).

Courts continue confirmation of arbitration awards

January 17, 2007 by Carlton Fields

Two recent rulings addressed the confirmation of arbitration awards:

The US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit affirmed the confirmation of an arbitration award in a non-insurance case, rejecting a contention that the award construed a contract in such a way that it violated a First Circuit standard that prohibits the interpretation of contracts “in a way that cannot possibly be described as plausible or rational.” Vital Basics Inc. v. Vertrue Inc., Case No. 05-2741 (1st Cir. Dec. 29, 2006).

A New York state court ruled that an arbitration award should be confirmed under New York law, since it was not arbitrary, capricious, or irrational, and the losing party had failed to prove its contention that the arbitrator had improperly prejudiced its rights and the integrity of the arbitral process due to purported ex parte contacts with opposing counsel. Mounier v. American Transit Ins. Co., Case No. 2005-03804 (NY Sup.Ct. App.Div. Jan. 9, 2007).